1 | /* |
2 | * Copyright (C) 2016-2019 Apple Inc. All rights reserved. |
3 | * |
4 | * Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without |
5 | * modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions |
6 | * are met: |
7 | * 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright |
8 | * notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer. |
9 | * 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright |
10 | * notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the |
11 | * documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution. |
12 | * |
13 | * THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY APPLE INC. ``AS IS'' AND ANY |
14 | * EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE |
15 | * IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR |
16 | * PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL APPLE INC. OR |
17 | * CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, |
18 | * EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, |
19 | * PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR |
20 | * PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY |
21 | * OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT |
22 | * (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE |
23 | * OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE. |
24 | */ |
25 | |
26 | #include "config.h" |
27 | #include "ShadowChicken.h" |
28 | |
29 | #include "CodeBlock.h" |
30 | #include "JSCInlines.h" |
31 | #include "ShadowChickenInlines.h" |
32 | #include <wtf/ListDump.h> |
33 | |
34 | namespace JSC { |
35 | |
36 | namespace ShadowChickenInternal { |
37 | static constexpr bool verbose = false; |
38 | } |
39 | |
40 | void ShadowChicken::Packet::dump(PrintStream& out) const |
41 | { |
42 | if (!*this) { |
43 | out.print("empty" ); |
44 | return; |
45 | } |
46 | |
47 | if (isPrologue()) { |
48 | String name = "?"_s ; |
49 | if (auto* function = jsDynamicCast<JSFunction*>(callee->vm(), callee)) { |
50 | name = function->name(callee->vm()); |
51 | if (name.isEmpty()) |
52 | name = "?"_s ; |
53 | } |
54 | |
55 | out.print( |
56 | "{callee = " , RawPointer(callee), ", frame = " , RawPointer(frame), ", callerFrame = " , |
57 | RawPointer(callerFrame), ", name = " , name, "}" ); |
58 | return; |
59 | } |
60 | |
61 | if (isTail()) { |
62 | out.print("tail-packet:{frame = " , RawPointer(frame), "}" ); |
63 | return; |
64 | } |
65 | |
66 | ASSERT(isThrow()); |
67 | out.print("throw" ); |
68 | } |
69 | |
70 | void ShadowChicken::Frame::dump(PrintStream& out) const |
71 | { |
72 | String name = "?"_s ; |
73 | if (auto* function = jsDynamicCast<JSFunction*>(callee->vm(), callee)) { |
74 | name = function->name(callee->vm()); |
75 | if (name.isEmpty()) |
76 | name = "?"_s ; |
77 | } |
78 | |
79 | out.print( |
80 | "{callee = " , *callee, ", frame = " , RawPointer(frame), ", isTailDeleted = " , |
81 | isTailDeleted, ", name = " , name, "}" ); |
82 | } |
83 | |
84 | ShadowChicken::ShadowChicken() |
85 | : m_logSize(Options::shadowChickenLogSize()) |
86 | { |
87 | // Allow one additional packet beyond m_logEnd. This is useful for the moment we |
88 | // log a packet when the log is full and force an update. At that moment the packet |
89 | // that is being logged should be included in the update because it may be |
90 | // a critical prologue needed to rationalize the current machine stack with the |
91 | // shadow stack. |
92 | m_log = static_cast<Packet*>(fastZeroedMalloc(sizeof(Packet) * (m_logSize + 1))); |
93 | m_logCursor = m_log; |
94 | m_logEnd = m_log + m_logSize; |
95 | } |
96 | |
97 | ShadowChicken::~ShadowChicken() |
98 | { |
99 | fastFree(m_log); |
100 | } |
101 | |
102 | void ShadowChicken::log(VM& vm, CallFrame* callFrame, const Packet& packet) |
103 | { |
104 | // This write is allowed because we construct the log with space for 1 additional packet. |
105 | *m_logCursor++ = packet; |
106 | update(vm, callFrame); |
107 | } |
108 | |
109 | void ShadowChicken::update(VM& vm, CallFrame* callFrame) |
110 | { |
111 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) { |
112 | dataLog("Running update on: " , *this, "\n" ); |
113 | WTFReportBacktrace(); |
114 | } |
115 | |
116 | const unsigned logCursorIndex = m_logCursor - m_log; |
117 | |
118 | // We need to figure out how to reconcile the current machine stack with our shadow stack. We do |
119 | // that by figuring out how much of the shadow stack to pop. We apply three different rules. The |
120 | // precise rule relies on the log. The log contains caller frames, which means that we know |
121 | // where we bottomed out after making any call. If we bottomed out but made no calls then 'exec' |
122 | // will tell us. That's why "highestPointSinceLastTime" will go no lower than exec. The third |
123 | // rule, based on comparing to the current real stack, is executed in a later loop. |
124 | CallFrame* highestPointSinceLastTime = callFrame; |
125 | for (unsigned i = logCursorIndex; i--;) { |
126 | Packet packet = m_log[i]; |
127 | if (packet.isPrologue()) { |
128 | CallFrame* watermark; |
129 | if (i && m_log[i - 1].isTail()) |
130 | watermark = packet.frame; |
131 | else |
132 | watermark = packet.callerFrame; |
133 | highestPointSinceLastTime = std::max(highestPointSinceLastTime, watermark); |
134 | } |
135 | } |
136 | |
137 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
138 | dataLog("Highest point since last time: " , RawPointer(highestPointSinceLastTime), "\n" ); |
139 | |
140 | while (!m_stack.isEmpty() && (m_stack.last().frame < highestPointSinceLastTime || m_stack.last().isTailDeleted)) |
141 | m_stack.removeLast(); |
142 | |
143 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
144 | dataLog(" Revised stack: " , listDump(m_stack), "\n" ); |
145 | |
146 | // It's possible that the top of stack is now tail-deleted. The stack no longer contains any |
147 | // frames below the log's high watermark. That means that we just need to look for the first |
148 | // occurence of a tail packet for the current stack top. |
149 | if (!m_stack.isEmpty()) { |
150 | ASSERT(!m_stack.last().isTailDeleted); |
151 | for (unsigned i = 0; i < logCursorIndex; ++i) { |
152 | Packet& packet = m_log[i]; |
153 | if (packet.isTail() && packet.frame == m_stack.last().frame) { |
154 | Frame& frame = m_stack.last(); |
155 | frame.thisValue = packet.thisValue; |
156 | frame.scope = packet.scope; |
157 | frame.codeBlock = packet.codeBlock; |
158 | frame.callSiteIndex = packet.callSiteIndex; |
159 | frame.isTailDeleted = true; |
160 | break; |
161 | } |
162 | } |
163 | } |
164 | |
165 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
166 | dataLog(" Revised stack: " , listDump(m_stack), "\n" ); |
167 | |
168 | // The log-based and callFrame-based rules require that ShadowChicken was enabled. The point of |
169 | // ShadowChicken is to give sensible-looking results even if we had not logged. This means that |
170 | // we need to reconcile the shadow stack and the real stack by actually looking at the real |
171 | // stack. This reconciliation allows the shadow stack to have extra tail-deleted frames, but it |
172 | // forbids it from diverging from the real stack on normal frames. |
173 | if (!m_stack.isEmpty()) { |
174 | Vector<Frame> stackRightNow; |
175 | StackVisitor::visit( |
176 | callFrame, vm, [&] (StackVisitor& visitor) -> StackVisitor::Status { |
177 | if (visitor->isInlinedFrame()) |
178 | return StackVisitor::Continue; |
179 | if (visitor->isWasmFrame()) { |
180 | // FIXME: Make shadow chicken work with Wasm. |
181 | // https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=165441 |
182 | return StackVisitor::Continue; |
183 | } |
184 | |
185 | bool isTailDeleted = false; |
186 | // FIXME: Make shadow chicken work with Wasm. |
187 | // https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=165441 |
188 | stackRightNow.append(Frame(jsCast<JSObject*>(visitor->callee().asCell()), visitor->callFrame(), isTailDeleted)); |
189 | return StackVisitor::Continue; |
190 | }); |
191 | stackRightNow.reverse(); |
192 | |
193 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
194 | dataLog(" Stack right now: " , listDump(stackRightNow), "\n" ); |
195 | |
196 | unsigned shadowIndex = 0; |
197 | unsigned rightNowIndex = 0; |
198 | while (shadowIndex < m_stack.size() && rightNowIndex < stackRightNow.size()) { |
199 | if (m_stack[shadowIndex].isTailDeleted) { |
200 | shadowIndex++; |
201 | continue; |
202 | } |
203 | |
204 | // We specifically don't use operator== here because we are using a less |
205 | // strict filter on equality of frames. For example, the scope pointer |
206 | // could change, but we wouldn't want to consider the frames different entities |
207 | // because of that because it's natural for the program to change scopes. |
208 | if (m_stack[shadowIndex].frame == stackRightNow[rightNowIndex].frame |
209 | && m_stack[shadowIndex].callee == stackRightNow[rightNowIndex].callee) { |
210 | shadowIndex++; |
211 | rightNowIndex++; |
212 | continue; |
213 | } |
214 | break; |
215 | } |
216 | m_stack.resize(shadowIndex); |
217 | |
218 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
219 | dataLog(" Revised stack: " , listDump(m_stack), "\n" ); |
220 | } |
221 | |
222 | // It's possible that the top stack frame is actually lower than highestPointSinceLastTime. |
223 | // Account for that here. |
224 | highestPointSinceLastTime = nullptr; |
225 | for (unsigned i = m_stack.size(); i--;) { |
226 | if (!m_stack[i].isTailDeleted) { |
227 | highestPointSinceLastTime = m_stack[i].frame; |
228 | break; |
229 | } |
230 | } |
231 | |
232 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
233 | dataLog(" Highest point since last time: " , RawPointer(highestPointSinceLastTime), "\n" ); |
234 | |
235 | // Set everything up so that we know where the top frame is in the log. |
236 | unsigned indexInLog = logCursorIndex; |
237 | |
238 | auto advanceIndexInLogTo = [&] (CallFrame* frame, JSObject* callee, CallFrame* callerFrame) -> bool { |
239 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
240 | dataLog(" Advancing to frame = " , RawPointer(frame), " from indexInLog = " , indexInLog, "\n" ); |
241 | if (indexInLog > logCursorIndex) { |
242 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
243 | dataLog(" Bailing.\n" ); |
244 | return false; |
245 | } |
246 | |
247 | unsigned oldIndexInLog = indexInLog; |
248 | |
249 | while (indexInLog--) { |
250 | Packet packet = m_log[indexInLog]; |
251 | |
252 | // If all callees opt into ShadowChicken, then this search will rapidly terminate when |
253 | // we find our frame. But if our frame's callee didn't emit a prologue packet because it |
254 | // didn't opt in, then we will keep looking backwards until we *might* find a different |
255 | // frame. If we've been given the callee and callerFrame as a filter, then it's unlikely |
256 | // that we will hit the wrong frame. But we don't always have that information. |
257 | // |
258 | // This means it's worth adding other filters. For example, we could track changes in |
259 | // stack size. Once we've seen a frame at some height, we're no longer interested in |
260 | // frames below that height. Also, we can break as soon as we see a frame higher than |
261 | // the one we're looking for. |
262 | // FIXME: Add more filters. |
263 | // https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=155685 |
264 | |
265 | if (packet.isPrologue() && packet.frame == frame |
266 | && (!callee || packet.callee == callee) |
267 | && (!callerFrame || packet.callerFrame == callerFrame)) { |
268 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
269 | dataLog(" Found at indexInLog = " , indexInLog, "\n" ); |
270 | return true; |
271 | } |
272 | } |
273 | |
274 | // This is an interesting eventuality. We will see this if ShadowChicken was not |
275 | // consistently enabled. We have a choice between: |
276 | // |
277 | // - Leaving the log index at -1, which will prevent the log from being considered. This is |
278 | // the most conservative. It means that we will not be able to recover tail-deleted frames |
279 | // from anything that sits above a frame that didn't log a prologue packet. This means |
280 | // that everyone who creates prologues must log prologue packets. |
281 | // |
282 | // - Restoring the log index to what it was before. This prevents us from considering |
283 | // whether this frame has tail-deleted frames behind it, but that's about it. The problem |
284 | // with this approach is that it might recover tail-deleted frames that aren't relevant. |
285 | // I haven't thought about this too deeply, though. |
286 | // |
287 | // It seems like the latter option is less harmful, so that's what we do. |
288 | indexInLog = oldIndexInLog; |
289 | |
290 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
291 | dataLog(" Didn't find it.\n" ); |
292 | return false; |
293 | }; |
294 | |
295 | Vector<Frame> toPush; |
296 | StackVisitor::visit( |
297 | callFrame, vm, [&] (StackVisitor& visitor) -> StackVisitor::Status { |
298 | if (visitor->isInlinedFrame()) { |
299 | // FIXME: Handle inlining. |
300 | // https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=155686 |
301 | return StackVisitor::Continue; |
302 | } |
303 | |
304 | if (visitor->isWasmFrame()) { |
305 | // FIXME: Make shadow chicken work with Wasm. |
306 | return StackVisitor::Continue; |
307 | } |
308 | |
309 | CallFrame* callFrame = visitor->callFrame(); |
310 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) { |
311 | dataLog(" Examining callFrame:" , RawPointer(callFrame), ", callee:" , RawPointer(callFrame->jsCallee()), ", callerFrame:" , RawPointer(callFrame->callerFrame()), "\n" ); |
312 | JSObject* callee = callFrame->jsCallee(); |
313 | if (auto* function = jsDynamicCast<JSFunction*>(callee->vm(), callee)) |
314 | dataLog(" Function = " , function->name(callee->vm()), "\n" ); |
315 | } |
316 | |
317 | if (callFrame == highestPointSinceLastTime) { |
318 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
319 | dataLog(" Bailing at " , RawPointer(callFrame), " because it's the highest point since last time\n" ); |
320 | |
321 | // FIXME: At this point the shadow stack may still have tail deleted frames |
322 | // that do not run into the current call frame but are left in the shadow stack. |
323 | // Those tail deleted frames should be validated somehow. |
324 | |
325 | return StackVisitor::Done; |
326 | } |
327 | |
328 | bool foundFrame = advanceIndexInLogTo(callFrame, callFrame->jsCallee(), callFrame->callerFrame()); |
329 | bool isTailDeleted = false; |
330 | JSScope* scope = nullptr; |
331 | CodeBlock* codeBlock = callFrame->codeBlock(); |
332 | JSValue scopeValue = callFrame->bytecodeIndex() && codeBlock && codeBlock->scopeRegister().isValid() |
333 | ? callFrame->registers()[codeBlock->scopeRegister().offset()].jsValue() |
334 | : jsUndefined(); |
335 | if (!scopeValue.isUndefined() && codeBlock->wasCompiledWithDebuggingOpcodes()) { |
336 | scope = jsCast<JSScope*>(scopeValue.asCell()); |
337 | RELEASE_ASSERT(scope->inherits<JSScope>(vm)); |
338 | } else if (foundFrame) { |
339 | scope = m_log[indexInLog].scope; |
340 | if (scope) |
341 | RELEASE_ASSERT(scope->inherits<JSScope>(vm)); |
342 | } |
343 | toPush.append(Frame(jsCast<JSObject*>(visitor->callee().asCell()), callFrame, isTailDeleted, callFrame->thisValue(), scope, codeBlock, callFrame->callSiteIndex())); |
344 | |
345 | if (indexInLog < logCursorIndex |
346 | // This condition protects us from the case where advanceIndexInLogTo didn't find |
347 | // anything. |
348 | && m_log[indexInLog].frame == toPush.last().frame) { |
349 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
350 | dataLog(" Going to loop through to find tail deleted frames using " , RawPointer(callFrame), " with indexInLog = " , indexInLog, " and push-stack top = " , toPush.last(), "\n" ); |
351 | for (;;) { |
352 | ASSERT(m_log[indexInLog].frame == toPush.last().frame); |
353 | |
354 | // Right now the index is pointing at a prologue packet of the last frame that |
355 | // we pushed. Peek behind that packet to see if there is a tail packet. If there |
356 | // is one then we know that there is a corresponding prologue packet that will |
357 | // tell us about a tail-deleted frame. |
358 | |
359 | if (!indexInLog) |
360 | break; |
361 | Packet tailPacket = m_log[indexInLog - 1]; |
362 | if (!tailPacket.isTail()) { |
363 | // Last frame that we recorded was not the outcome of a tail call. So, there |
364 | // will not be any more deleted frames. |
365 | // FIXME: We might want to have a filter here. Consider that this was a tail |
366 | // marker for a tail call to something that didn't log anything. It should |
367 | // be sufficient to give the tail marker a copy of the caller frame. |
368 | // https://bugs.webkit.org/show_bug.cgi?id=155687 |
369 | break; |
370 | } |
371 | indexInLog--; // Skip over the tail packet. |
372 | |
373 | // FIXME: After a few iterations the tail packet referenced frame may not be the |
374 | // same as the original callFrame for the real stack frame we started with. |
375 | // It is unclear when we should break. |
376 | |
377 | if (!advanceIndexInLogTo(tailPacket.frame, nullptr, nullptr)) { |
378 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
379 | dataLog("Can't find prologue packet for tail: " , RawPointer(tailPacket.frame), "\n" ); |
380 | // We were unable to locate the prologue packet for this tail packet. |
381 | // This is rare but can happen in a situation like: |
382 | // function foo() { |
383 | // ... call some deeply tail-recursive function, causing a random number of log processings. |
384 | // return bar(); // tail call |
385 | // } |
386 | break; |
387 | } |
388 | Packet packet = m_log[indexInLog]; |
389 | bool isTailDeleted = true; |
390 | RELEASE_ASSERT(tailPacket.scope->inherits<JSScope>(vm)); |
391 | toPush.append(Frame(packet.callee, packet.frame, isTailDeleted, tailPacket.thisValue, tailPacket.scope, tailPacket.codeBlock, tailPacket.callSiteIndex)); |
392 | } |
393 | } |
394 | |
395 | return StackVisitor::Continue; |
396 | }); |
397 | |
398 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
399 | dataLog(" Pushing: " , listDump(toPush), "\n" ); |
400 | |
401 | for (unsigned i = toPush.size(); i--;) |
402 | m_stack.append(toPush[i]); |
403 | |
404 | // We want to reset the log. There is a fun corner-case: there could be a tail marker at the end |
405 | // of this log. We could make that work by setting isTailDeleted on the top of stack, but that |
406 | // would require more corner cases in the complicated reconciliation code above. That code |
407 | // already knows how to handle a tail packet at the beginning, so we just leverage that here. |
408 | if (logCursorIndex && m_log[logCursorIndex - 1].isTail()) { |
409 | m_log[0] = m_log[logCursorIndex - 1]; |
410 | m_logCursor = m_log + 1; |
411 | } else |
412 | m_logCursor = m_log; |
413 | |
414 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
415 | dataLog(" After pushing: " , listDump(m_stack), "\n" ); |
416 | |
417 | // Remove tail frames until the number of tail deleted frames is small enough. |
418 | const unsigned maxTailDeletedFrames = Options::shadowChickenMaxTailDeletedFramesSize(); |
419 | if (m_stack.size() > maxTailDeletedFrames) { |
420 | unsigned numberOfTailDeletedFrames = 0; |
421 | for (const Frame& frame : m_stack) { |
422 | if (frame.isTailDeleted) |
423 | numberOfTailDeletedFrames++; |
424 | } |
425 | if (numberOfTailDeletedFrames > maxTailDeletedFrames) { |
426 | unsigned dstIndex = 0; |
427 | unsigned srcIndex = 0; |
428 | while (srcIndex < m_stack.size()) { |
429 | Frame frame = m_stack[srcIndex++]; |
430 | if (numberOfTailDeletedFrames > maxTailDeletedFrames && frame.isTailDeleted) { |
431 | numberOfTailDeletedFrames--; |
432 | continue; |
433 | } |
434 | m_stack[dstIndex++] = frame; |
435 | } |
436 | m_stack.shrink(dstIndex); |
437 | } |
438 | } |
439 | |
440 | if (ShadowChickenInternal::verbose) |
441 | dataLog(" After clean-up: " , *this, "\n" ); |
442 | } |
443 | |
444 | void ShadowChicken::visitChildren(SlotVisitor& visitor) |
445 | { |
446 | for (unsigned i = m_logCursor - m_log; i--;) { |
447 | JSObject* callee = m_log[i].callee; |
448 | if (callee != Packet::tailMarker() && callee != Packet::throwMarker()) |
449 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(callee); |
450 | if (callee != Packet::throwMarker()) |
451 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(m_log[i].scope); |
452 | if (callee == Packet::tailMarker()) { |
453 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(m_log[i].thisValue); |
454 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(m_log[i].codeBlock); |
455 | } |
456 | } |
457 | |
458 | for (unsigned i = m_stack.size(); i--; ) { |
459 | Frame& frame = m_stack[i]; |
460 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(frame.thisValue); |
461 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(frame.callee); |
462 | if (frame.scope) |
463 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(frame.scope); |
464 | if (frame.codeBlock) |
465 | visitor.appendUnbarriered(frame.codeBlock); |
466 | } |
467 | } |
468 | |
469 | void ShadowChicken::reset() |
470 | { |
471 | m_logCursor = m_log; |
472 | m_stack.clear(); |
473 | } |
474 | |
475 | void ShadowChicken::dump(PrintStream& out) const |
476 | { |
477 | out.print("{stack = [" , listDump(m_stack), "], log = [" ); |
478 | |
479 | CommaPrinter comma; |
480 | unsigned limit = static_cast<unsigned>(m_logCursor - m_log); |
481 | out.print("\n" ); |
482 | for (unsigned i = 0; i < limit; ++i) |
483 | out.print("\t" , comma, "[" , i, "] " , m_log[i], "\n" ); |
484 | out.print("]}" ); |
485 | } |
486 | |
487 | JSArray* ShadowChicken::functionsOnStack(JSGlobalObject* globalObject, CallFrame* callFrame) |
488 | { |
489 | VM& vm = globalObject->vm(); |
490 | auto scope = DECLARE_THROW_SCOPE(vm); |
491 | JSArray* result = constructEmptyArray(globalObject, nullptr); |
492 | RETURN_IF_EXCEPTION(scope, nullptr); |
493 | |
494 | iterate( |
495 | vm, callFrame, |
496 | [&] (const Frame& frame) -> bool { |
497 | result->push(globalObject, frame.callee); |
498 | scope.releaseAssertNoException(); // This function is only called from tests. |
499 | return true; |
500 | }); |
501 | |
502 | return result; |
503 | } |
504 | |
505 | } // namespace JSC |
506 | |
507 | |